The ESG would like to thank Gibtelecom for joining us in the recent 5G debate.

Full attendance during highly inclement weather, on a Friday evening, further confirmed the strong interest in this subject and we commend everyone who attended and enriched the evening. We are also very grateful to Owen Smith for the role he played as mediator/chair, which allowed the debate to move along covering both sides of the issue fairly.

Gibtelecom explained their position on how they roll out telecommunications services in Gibraltar today and how they envisage the use of 5G going forward.

ESG presented the other side of the story –about the speed in which this technology is being rolled out throughout the world, and concerns, widely shared, about the possible negative effects on human health of such relentless growth.

The debate saw 2 full hours of presentation, Q&A session and open floor and could easily have continued. It is expected that there will be further opportunities for this issue to be aired over the coming weeks.

Overall the ESG believes the evening achieved its objective when it first proposed such a public debate at a recent DPC meeting when Gibtelecom submitted 5G mast applications. We do not rule out any more public meetings in future.

What is clear is there is a real interest and thirst for clarity and information in Gibraltar about the technology that exists in our lives today; a technology that creates an ever more interesting, diverse and sophisticated world, but raises questions about the possible health impacts that must be explored fully.

Look out for more discussions coming along soon and we thank GBC for filming this lively and first ever 5G debate to take place on the Rock.

May the debate continue!

The ESG has voiced concerns, which have been shared by others, over the ever-increasing electro magnetic radiation pollution deriving from the gadgets we use and the masts that service these.

While acknowledging that the use of this technology is an inevitable aspect of our every day life, we continue to believe that careful use at a personal level, and the precautionary principle applied at an industrial level, should always be applied.

The group held separate meetings recently with the Chief Minister and Gibtelecom during 2019 to share concerns about 5G coming to Gibraltar. At the last DPC mtg Gibtelecom received approval to install 4 masts for testing and data collection purposes. The ESG believes it is now time for a public debate to be held to enable a full, free and informative discussion to take place.  A date has been set for the 24^th January at 7pm.

Please read following information:

1. The ESG and Gibtelecom have agreed it would be in the public interest to hold such a meeting together to ensure both sides of the story are covered in detail and invite people interested to register at email: 5Gdebate@gibtelecom.net

2. Registration by email will start as from 15^th January and not before. Due to venue restrictions, and to ensure a full exchange of views can take place, there will be a limit on numbers and the first 45 people to register will attend.

3. Should interest exceed capacity there has already been discussion of holding a second debate.

4. We are also asking those registering to please submit a question or comment you would like to see debated with your email.

5. Only those who have registered and received confirmation will be able to attend.

6. Debate will be held on the 24^th January at 7pm at the Lecture Room in the John Mackintosh Hall. (Friday). Duration; 1.5 to 2 hours max

                                                ================

With applications presented to DPC today for the proposed introduction of 5G in Gibraltar the ESG is once again calling for the Precautionary Principle to be followed until such time as exploratory testing results and safety reports held by Gibtelecom have been shared with the public.

The ESG frequently consulted with both industry and Government during the installation of 3 and 4G and believes that total transparency present at the time was positive and delivered best possible results for all sides.

“The announcement of 5G antennae applications for Gibraltar has come as a surprise. We have been expecting the release of information from industry and Government on safety reports and testing outcomes since the exposition held by Gibtelecom in the Piazza last summer,” said a spokesperson for the ESG.

Many countries throughout the world are adopting a precautionary approach on 5G, with scientists, medical professionals and politicians demanding safety first and the ESG believes Gibraltar should follow suit. “We are concerned that the telecommunication industry continues to apply dated safety standards on a technology that has grown and changed beyond all recognition and become so much a part of our lives.”

“The ESG is not opposed to progress or to being convinced of the safety of 5G. However we do seek assurances based on independent research and hope this will be forthcoming. Until such time we will remain opposed to its introduction in Gibraltar.”

The ESG has been witnessing the rise of 5G technology in the international public media with growing concern. While the UK Government has dismissed a close to 20,000 strong petition urging Parliament to consider the potential health and ecological impacts of this new phase technology, there are other countries announcing bans on its introduction on these same concerns. Officials from three European countries, as well as a USA State, have called for bans and further research to better understand the fears linked to 5G, and its impact on the natural world and on public health.

 

The ESG calls on Gibraltar to join Poland, Switzerland, Brussels and Louisiana, in adopting a similar halt of the 5G rollout until further and robust proof of its safety is attained from preferably a non-industry source.

 

Public statements:

Brussels Becomes First Major City to Halt 5G Due to Health Effects

The statement was made by Céline Fremault, the Minister of the Government of the Brussels-Capital Region, responsible for Housing, Quality of Life, Environment and Energy. From an interview last Friday, with L’Echo:

“I cannot welcome such technology if the radiation standards, which must protect the citizen, are not respected, 5G or not. The people of Brussels are not guinea pigs whose health I can sell at a profit. We cannot leave anything to doubt.”

– Céline Fremault, Minister of the Government (Brussels-Captial Region), responsible for Housing, Quality of Life, Environment and Energy

Switzerland
This week the canton of Vaud announced it would temporarily freeze permits to install new 5G transmitters. The resolution calls for a ban on 5G transmitter installation at least until the Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN) has finished its study into the effects of the new technology.

Poland
In what is surely an unprecedented and  groundbreaking action, the Prime Minister of Poland, Mateusz Morawiecki, has personally backed an International Appeal to stop the controversial roll-out of 5G electromagnetic microwave telecommunication transmissions.

In Poland, the public are being used as guinea pigs in a 5G experiment to test the efficacy of the technology. The following cities are being used in the trial: Warsaw, Lodz, Gliwice.

 

Louisiana Becomes First State To Call For A Study On Health Impacts Of 5G

On May 29, the Louisiana House unanimously voted to have the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality and the Department of Health study the effects of 5G technology on the environment and public health. The Louisiana legislature passed House Resolution 145 with a vote of 103 in favor and zero representatives voting against the measure. The bill calls for the results of the study to be submitted to the Louisiana House Committee on Natural Resources and Environment as well as the House Committee on Health and Welfare no later than sixty days prior to the start of the 2020 Regular Session of the Louisiana Legislature.

Please Note; this has nothing to do with Huawey business competition, but the uncertainty of 5G to public health.

 

In our second 2020 broadcast we have great expectations from a fresh government and highly environmental manifesto – that has aspiration to deliver a Child Friendly and Green City. We share this vision, of course, and want to see measures to achieve this in place as fast as possible. We are now seeking and holding meetings with Government in various areas to ascertain their plan of action. This week we held a lengthy and productive meeting with several of our committee members and the Minister for the Environment and his team and ran through all our objectives. We will continue to monitor issues until such time as we see these fully addressed. You can find our Core List of Objectives at the home page of our website at  : www.esg-gib.net

Later this month we meet with the Minister for Transport. Following a lengthy understanding with the previous Minister Paul Balban, the ESG looks ahead to re-establish contact on these issues with Minister Daryanani on Traffic and Transport matters to address Gibraltar’s most pressing issues in these areas. This topic is huge – we will talk about cleaner technology, about the need for urgent and decisive action, about cross border vehicles and the construction industry contribution, and enforcement measures to tackle worst offenders.  The Govt STTP  “Sustainable Traffic and Transport Plan” produced after wide consultation and preparation has within it a number of bold measures which, if applied, could bring about changes that many seek.

We are hopeful that reports explaining Government’s plan of action in every sector to co-deliver a Child Friendly and Green city will be released soon.

Just some info for those of you interested. Following positive feedback from our 1^st 5G debate we are currently exploring a follow up and will also be participating in a dedicated Viewpoint Programme on this topic very soon!

Now we are out of Europe politically speaking, it raises big concerns for us. One of our key targets since we started in the year 2000 was cleaning up the petrochemical industry across the border, namely CEPSA. We had representation in the EU Parliament, legislation that even the EU could not argue was being flagrantly ignored, despite strong Spanish lobbying,  we managed to get the spotlight all the way from Brussels on to this huge industry, saw audits undertaken and measures introduced to drag it up a few notches into a measurably cleaner operation.  This loss of redress deeply concerns us. We shall be studying our Environmental MOU’s to see how we can protect ourselves and the environment from transgressions caused by our neighbours.

Yesterday saw heavy emissions from a chimney at this plant blow across Puente Mayorga and towards La Linea. It appeared to have lasted a considerable time with Verdemar complaining late last night about the heavy smoke blowing while people slept. They talked about sulphurous fumes.

The ESG detected strong chemical smells in the south district, that our local authorities thought could possibly be linked to the smoky emissions in Spain. The smells in Gibraltar were very much like you find close to the Refinery itself, a sweet and sickly smell.  During our Bucket sampling days we learnt to distinguish between chemical smells and yesterday gave us reason to believe the fumes were solvent based VOC (volatile organic compounds).

We hope there won’t be any repetition of these fumes but should this happen it may be time for us to revive our bucket sampler and grab an air sample!

Thanks for listening –

 

Hi there- this our first radio broadcast for 2020! We start the year planning and strategising best way forward in a number of areas important to the ESG and to many in the community.

Very recently, and on the back of 5G mast applications presented to DPC by Gibtelecom, the ESG organised a public debate that saw Gibtelecom and the ESG present information and concerns on this ever growing technology to those present. The interest and knowledge displayed by many in the audience was evident and the thirst for more discussion also clear.

The meeting was lively, busy and informative. The issue behind 5G represents a variety of areas of interest/query and concern. Thus the mtg focused only on whether 5G, as is being discussed globally, will be set up in Gibraltar any time soon – and what exactly this meant.

We believe assurances were delivered on current plans but many questions relating to this topic remain and we are now exploring the possibility of a follow up public debate.

Look out for ‘A Brighter Future” GBC series that plans to feature this debate and subject next week. Viewpoint is also preparing a special programme on this issue.

The debate has certainly started – and will continue for some time still. Our view of updating safety regulations for this industry tailored specifically for Gibraltar needs, and the application of the Precautionary Principle,  remains firmly in place.

 While on the subject of A Brighter Future we urge those interested in Gibraltar’s environment and climate change to look at this series currently online, as it aims to draw attention to our wonderful biodiversity, the impressive community participation and support for our nation wide Clean up Campaign and in Episode 3, information on where exactly you can take your non kitchen waste for recycling – it informs on facilities, waste types etc.  Think this will surprise many, and also encourage those who think recycling is not being done in Gibraltar and is a waste of time. It clearly is, on an impressive scale, and the more people who use our facilities, the better we will do. Another feature in episodes 1 and 3 is coverage on Climate Change action, marches, and interviews by the Coalition for Climate Action etc. This Coalition is currently also planning its campaign for 2020.

Another issue never far from our thoughts is Transport. We are seeking a meeting with the new Minister for Transport where we shall present our concerns and recommendations in the hope that urgency will be applied to this issue. Updates on this soon!

DPC – that’s the Development and Planning Commission – resume its monthly sessions next week with the first 2020 mtg happening on the 4^th February. A large project that could interest the public is the old casino site on Europa Road and the replacement building planned for this site. The ESG is opposed to the scale of this project, which we believe impacts on an important part of our natural heritage including the Botanic Gardens and Nature Reserve. DPC meeting is open to the public and starts at 9.30am.

In 2020 the ESG will be following up with various Ministers on issues within their portfolios which carry significant environmental impacts. We will also run additional debates and discussions on key areas of interest and concern to our members that are also in the public interest.

Visit our website at esg-gib.net for press releases and newsletters. Email us at esg@gibtelecom.net  . Thanks for listening.

ESG Radio Newsletter November 28^th 2019

Hi there!

During the past few weeks, and, post elections, things have been normalising somewhat. We have followed proceedings very closely and with much interest. The ESG has published its List of Objectives to coincide with elections over many years and this proved very helpful when lobbying the parties. It also helped ensure that many of our issues were covered in the manifestos subsequently launched by them. If you visit our website at www.esg-gib.net  you will find details of our objectives as well as our press statements and transcripts of our radio broadcasts, both current and historic. You can also click here: http://www.esg-gib.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/LIST-OF-OBJECTIVES-September-2019_.pdf

We now enter a period of follow up with meetings with government and other parties and will be pressing for action in the areas we are most concerned about – these include climate change, traffic, pollution and more.

Last week the DPC, (the Development & Planning Commission), held a meeting with an agenda that included projects such as Amar Bakery and Rialto Cinema.  These were deferred – among the issues discussed though were two applications for 5G antennae.

Our ESG representative on the panel explained our position and concerns regarding the roll-out of 5G across the globe – and more specifically in Gibraltar, calling for more information to be made available to the public on the questions being asked by scientists, doctors and politicians about the safety of this technology. Gibtelecom Jansen Reyes agreed to participate in a public debate where a question and answer session can take place and a productive discussion can follow. Details of the 5G debate will be released soon  – hopefully this side of Christmas.

We can’t let you go without sharing some news on our flagship campaign Clean up the World. We are pleased to confirm that voluntary clean ups continue and we have been able to loan out equipment to a few teams keen on helping the environment.

Weather has proved a deterrent for our avid team hoping to revisit our ‘boat access only’ site at Seven Sisters to continue working there, but perhaps we will get a lucky break soon.

That’s it for now. The next DPC meeting, and last one of the year, will take place on the 12^th December.  For those who may be unaware you can find the agenda for that mtg online a week before the actual commission meeting. It is quite possible that a  number of large projects will be considered that day

As the year inexorably draws to a close we are of course reminded that Christmas is not far off. Please be thoughtful this year with your purchasing and waste – remember that the West is buckling under the weight of plastics we consume and dispose of, and Christmas is an especially bad time for this.

Thanks for listening – please get in contact if you would like any more information on our objectives – just drop us an email at esg@gibtelecom.net

ESG Philosophy and Motivation

September 2019

In 2000 the ESG formed as an NGO to campaign on environmental issues. Since 2003 we have published our “List of Objectives” and lobbied all parties standing for election to ensure the environment is placed firmly on the political agenda. We have a good grasp of local and regional environmental issues and have the advantage of experience and knowledge that comes with passionately following and researching these for two decades.

The ‘environment’ and the crisis of ‘climate change’ are now mainstream news. However achieving meaningful change to address these most serious challenges requires adaption and use of appropriate economic and technological systems to make our societies more sustainable and less polluting. This “adaption period” is critical to avert the worst effects of climate change and nations everywhere are being called upon to forge such plans. Gibraltar must also develop a climate plan that sets out targets to reduce our pollution and use of fossil fuels in as short a time as possible and include all relevant activity on the Rock.

Our group’s focus has been on cleaning up and making Gibraltar a healthier and more pleasant land to live, while at the same time celebrating and protecting the incredible nature we are so fortunate to inhabit. Our historic work on local and regional pollution and seeking application of best available technology and regulations is well known and we have always been conscious of the benefits to the wider climate impacts by reducing our pollution.

We also call for higher environmental protection standards than legally permitted elsewhere, because of our size and proximity to sources of pollution. ‘The Precautionary Principle’ is a critical tool we have also called upon to be applied when legislation fails to provide adequate protection for people or the environment.

By cleaning up our polluting sources we are also improving our health and quality of life, which is obviously a basic human right, and one we should all aspire to enjoy.

Gibraltar’s size and political situation makes achieving true sustainability in terms of waste/energy/food etc. impossible. The trade in fossil fuels carried out in Gibraltar, the Bay and North Africa is part of a global reliance on oil and plans must soon come into line to transition away from this practice. However, the petrochemical industries across the bay continue to expand and are a stark reminder that whatever improvements we make in Gibraltar – and make them we must – our backdrop is one that is literally killing the planet. Efforts should be increased at a local and cross border level to seek a moratorium of such industries and clean up this regional environmental hotspot. In this regard the ESG and our partners can be proud of the decade long fight we took to Brussels and the EU, to clean up the large Oil Refinery located in the bay, a few kilometres from Gibraltar in San Roque, and during which time, was operating to 3^rd world standards. Under the current climate crisis, we are studying the possibilities of once more taking on this major challenge as industries, major reclamation works and rampant urbanisation threatens the region.

The ESG has formed several successful partnerships over the years with local, regional & global NGOs and embarked on several campaigns.

KEY ISSUES INCLUDE

• 1. CLIMATE CHANGE

• 2. ADHERENCE TO EU (OR HIGHER) ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS BEYOND BREXIT

• 3. ENERGY

• 4. POLLUTION –   (LAND/SEA, PORT & DOCKYARD IMPACTS – AIRPORT & BORDER)

• 5. TRAFFIC & TRANSPORT

• 6. BUNKERING

• 7. CROSS BORDER

• 8.  EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES

• 9.  SEWAGE TREATMENT

• 10. WASTE / RECYCLING / LITTER

• 11. PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT

• 12. CONSERVATION

• 13. EMF RADIATION 

• 14. TOURISM AND BEACHES

• 15. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION & MANAGEMENT PLAN

1. CLIMATE CHANGE    

Gibraltar has serious challenges on its journey towards becoming carbon free. Government has declared a Climate Emergency Pledge and the ESG has joined other local environmental and heritage NGOs to press for an ambitious and independently monitored programme for the decarbonising of our community. This coalition known as the ‘Coalition for Climate Action’ has emerged from public meetings organised by the ESG in 2019, in response to the growing local and global civic call for action on climate change.

The coalition wants urgent action on:

ŸTransport   ŸEnergy   ŸPollution   ŸWaste   ŸDevelopment   ŸTrade in Fossil Fuel

and calls for a funded and cross party supported, independent climate body, to be tasked with  the rolling out of an agreed programme within a strict timeframe, that is binding on all future   administrations, to achieve the transition away from a carbon intensive society.

(See No.16 for EAMP)

2. ADHERENCE TO EU (OR HIGHER) ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS BEYOND BREXIT

ESG commends Governments commitment to continue to apply EU environmental standards    in Gibraltar, even once out of the European Commission, and expects all parties to sustain this. As stated above, our ideal objective would be to see higher than EU standards applied when these fail to deliver adequate protection due to our small size. Additionally, our aim now, under a Climate Change Pledge, would be to set goals that will radically transform our industry, transport, and trade to decarbonise Gibraltar as far as possible and as quickly as can be done. (i.e. a change in approach and strategy and not merely a legal requirement).

3. ENERGY  

     Since 2002 the ESG has been fighting air pollution from aging power stations and calling for research into and application of most appropriate renewable energy systems. We have recognised the interim need for a state of the art modern power station to be set up using best available technology and monitoring standards, and for this to be run until it can be replaced increasingly by clean technology. Clearly Gibraltar requires significant and stable power supply for desalination purposes as well as powering homes and businesses.

     We have been waiting for this interim power station to be set up since 2009/2010 when the previous administration planned to build this at Lathbury Parade. The present administration reversed this decision in 2011/2012, and set about building this, instead, in the NW flank of Gibraltar in the port area, to be run on Diesel/LNG gas. This change has brought with it, numerous other factors, including need for reclamation. We are concerned that, while the primary use of gas over diesel should produce less pollution in the immediate area, that full commissioning takes place as soon as possible. A recent announcement has confirmed this to be end of this year. We will continue to monitor this.  Real-time Stack monitoring – a measure called for by the ESG – should further assure residents of emission quality from the power station. Of course gas, while burning more cleanly than diesel, is nevertheless a fossil fuel and its use must be phased out in favour of renewable energy technologies.

     Energy production for Gibraltar has to take a central role in the action on Climate. This is a key factor we believe must be included in the Climate Change Emergency Plan that has to follow a strict timeframe outside of any other EU targets or plans.

     ESG supports a variety of renewable energy systems for Gibraltar including solar, vertical axis land based wind, offshore wind farms, and marine current turbines. The group hopes that a consensual approach on the medium and long-term planning for investment into renewable energy systems in Gibraltar will be found to accelerate our progress in getting there.  A major objective is in identifying, via robust research, a clean and sustainable alternative to oil, for the production of our potable water, via desalination.

4. POLLUTION

This is a very important area for us, which we work on pretty much all the time as we file reports on     pollution incidences and help members of the public who share their concerns and reports with us. Until pollution excesses disappear we shall continue to fight these and press for lasting solutions to pollution by way of investment in clean technologies, removal of out-dated industrial practices and effectively enforcing polluter paying principle, which if heavy enough, will start turning the tide. The use of best available technology and practice should be enforced in our small town.

The links between reducing/eliminating pollution and helping address climate change have always been very clear to the ESG and provided us with extra motivation in our 20-year struggle.

     Specifically the ESG considers the issues are the following as at September 2019:

     a. Real-time Stations & Mobile Air Monitors

     Pods have now been placed throughout Gibraltar at a number of hotspots. After some months                  data is now posted online and can be found at: www.gibraltarairquality.gi

     We welcome the steps taken to capture air sampling in areas many of us believe air quality to be       seriously compromised and we can take heart that now we can see what the picture looks like.

     The pods provide ‘indicative levels’ of pollution and by virtue of their design, size, etc. will not be relied upon as heavily as permanent real-time stations. However these indicator levels will be very useful to the authorities in implementing change as are used elsewhere, as well as of keen interest to NGOs like us and the public at large.

-We remain convinced of the need for one of the real-time stations in the south to be placed in the NW district (as soon as possible) so that this data can also be inserted into our air quality reports.

     ESG is studying the trends of the pollution levels captured by the pods, as data has only been available for a few weeks. We regret that vocs, (volatile organic compounds, produced when refuelling, paint spraying, etc.), are not currently measured by pods at key sites where these gases will be present. We are pushing for this to be added without delay. (Sites include nr Harbour Views and GibDock). Update: early days for the pods as they are moved around Gibraltar and fine tuned to better reflect the areas and the pollutants they should be covering. We continue to monitor this very closely.

     b. Current Power Stations and Skip generators

     The present mothballing of the power stations has been welcomed. Their complete dismantlement and removal once the LNG Gas/Diesel Station is fully commissioned will bring about a new era in power generation, one that will nevertheless be an interim step to Gibraltar moving towards ever growing reliance on renewable energy. The ESG continues to monitor the situation to speed up this process as quickly as possible. The date suggested of the end of the year by Govt and GEA will hopefully come to fruition and will finally remove chronic sources of air and noise pollution from our power stations and skid generators.

     c. GibDock

    The ESG has publicly called upon both this industry and the authorities to address the environmental impacts from the dockyard activity. We were most concerned when back in 2007? three large housing estates were built immediately adjacent to the dockyard raising issues of conflict that inevitably followed. We have seen years of heavy pollution from this industry where residents are bearing the brunt and potential health consequences and time has come for this to be either closed or see appropriate investment in mitigation to eliminate operational impacts.

     d. Onshore Power Supply (connection and conversion)

     We have long called for the installation of onshore power connection and conversion, (also known as cold ironing), to be mandatory for vessels using our harbour. Indeed a Green Port Status is increasingly calling for this facility to be part of its compliance. Works have started to set up this facility at the Extension Jetties site. All other sites like GibDock, South Mole, Rooke area, Detached and North Moles, should all have the option to be able to do this, as soon as possible. This land based power supply would remove pollution from marine fuel engine emissions from the quayside (especially from idling over long periods), which, in Gibraltar, means improving air quality for nearby residents. Instead the emissions would come from a cleaner burning new power station.

e. Ships at anchor

Fuming offshore tankers are a fairly common sight to us here in Gibraltar. Indeed the number of ships offshore creates smog and worsens our air quality to exceed that of land based traffic. Internationally legislation is in place to further clean up emissions from vessels (particulates) once they enter the harbour area. However such implementation is some way off and Governments commitment to introduce emission controls on particulates from vessels is very much welcomed. Other measures already in place to convert to cleaner fuels when entering port and sulphur limits in fuels used by vessels visiting Gibraltar works quite well at present for a high percentage of vessels. Enforcement against errant polluting vessels needs to be tightened up and quicker response time is needed with less reliance on the public to feed in reports.

f. Cruise Ships and Super Yachts

It is quite common to see large cruise ships that visit Gibraltar smoke heavily at berth at the North Mole, often for long periods of time. This pollution needs to be quantified, as there are several residential estates and play areas downwind of these vessels. We understand that some cruise ships draw too much power for these to use onshore provision (once this is in place). There is much variety in the cruise liners that come to Gibraltar, in terms of size/ energy draw/ efficiency and length of stay. Their environmental impacts should be fully understood. Super Yachts can also be quite polluting and the ESG would like to know what rules and standards apply locally to limit pollution from these very large and fuel hungry vessels to manage their impact while at berth.

    g. Vapour recovery technology

     Should be applied on all fuelling transactions from shipping to eliminate fugitive fumes during transactions that periodically sweep through neighbourhoods. Additionally all land-based activity dealing in any type of fuelling should always incorporate vapour recovery as best practice.

h. Road idling

     Rules regarding unnecessary idling of engines by all road vehicles, needs to be enforced. Despite

     initial efforts by the Department of Environment and Transport, to inform and remind the public about the health impacts from idling, this practice continues widespread in Gibraltar because of lack of fines and enforcement. We need larger and more signs. We need penalties to be applied as examples and deterrents. There should be idling free zones with stricter rules – outside schools, narrow and busy streets, the border, etc. Tourist vehicles must be reminded of their responsibilities not just to their clients to keep a cool bus/taxi, but also the impact these high number of vehicles imposes on everyone else. Idling should be banned in principle and fines should be imposed as is done in the UK and elsewhere to protect public health. Coach idling in the Mid Town car park creates a serious pollution problem and must be addressed.

i. Airport associated noise and air pollution impact

As airport activity grows so must monitoring of the impact on air quality and noise levels. Refuelling     of planes takes place v frequently and in close proximity to airport and to passengers moving in and out of aeroplanes. What is the impact of these fumes on people? Can this be done to tighter regulations?

h. Border issues

     The chaos of the border environment continues with the heavy volume of traffic/runway closures/Spanish customs actions. The second hand buses used to provide the border-town run are not EU compliant and should not be used on our roads. It is hoped that once the runway tunnel is complete, that a new plan to mobilise current pedestrians will have been forged. The absence of such a plan will potentially lead to an increase in motorised traffic coming into Gibraltar, as people will not be willing to walk the much longer new route round the tunnel. This is a major issue and needs addressing urgently. The park and ride facility, initially conceived for the use of the large car park at Devil’s Tower Road, should be exclusively reverted for the purpose intended, once Bassadone vehicles are out.

5. TRANSPORT & TRAFFIC

     Transport and Traffic have fast become one of the heaviest environmental impacts of our day. We have campaigned for a holistic transport plan that was finally published a few years ago and which is slowly being implemented. Some improvements have been achieved but there is much left to do to provide calm roads, clean air, and encourage more of us to leave our motorised vehicles behind.

     Apart from personal and commercial transport, we have the additional load linked to development, which is a constant, and together, make for an unhealthy environment and in places, intolerable levels of traffic. This ‘temporary’ yet ‘constant’ presence of diesel chugging transport degrades our quality of life and very importantly adds to the consumption of fuel and production of kerbside pollution and CO2. The opportunity of influencing change to cleaner transport clearly lies in Government hands via policy and we hope a climate emergency will see all party manifestos declaring their plan for decarbonising our transport in Gibraltar. Here we look at specifics regarding transport as follows: –

• STTP (Sustainable Traffic & Transport Plan) Cross party support for this detailed plan would ensure a speedier implementation for the benefit of all the community
• Idling is a real curse be it from land based transport or vessels in water. Diesel fumes are carcinogenic thus it is imperative to urgently stop the habit of idling. Stronger campaigns are needed with information promoting the harmful effects on health and strategic fining must be introduced to deter others
• Diesel itself is being phased out in Gibraltar and that is a positive development. However this imperative is directed at resident cars only and does not address commercial or visitor vehicles
• Incentives for clean running vehicles have been used and it is hoped there will be a lot more done in this regard in 2019/2020
• Incentivising clean running vehicles (hybrids and electric) and discouraging fossil fuelled vehicles should be embraced more aggressively as this could help bring about necessary changes faster and a cleaner environment
• Visitors should be advised to park in designated parking areas that are clearly marked, where machines are constantly serviced (!), and where they are not routinely clamped because of failure of the former. Park and Ride facility at Devil’s Tower Road with increased provision of public transport is necessary
• Removal of second hand buses that a) are highly polluting and b) cannot switch off engines and run A/C must be a priority. These buses are as busy as the Government owned buses that serve Gibraltar. The Citibuses run very busy routes, are polluting and create pollution hotspots wherever they are. This is bad for locals, visitors, and for our reputation. We think that given the demands on transport and mass visitor movement in Gibraltar, that this should be done using clean technology to improve local environment for both locals and visitors alike. Some form of transition fund/loan should be available to help companies upgrade to clean transport
• Control of car ownership to limit numbers on roads regardless of ability to pay for multiple vehicles
• Emission standards testing of vehicle emissions must be applied more widely and to strict and stringent standards
• Government hybrid buses to be urgently introduced to run on flat routes
• Noise pollution can be very onerous  on  our  roads.  Motorbikes  (especially those with modified exhausts), commercial vehicles and construction machinery are the worst offenders. Noise pollution needs to be tackled more vigorously in Gibraltar.
• Mobile Phones & driving is awidespread practice in Gibraltar that must be better controlled. A matter of time before a serious accident happens due to this illegal activity
• Pavement provision and pedestrianisation – parts of Upper Town in particular could benefit from both these measures. Indeed some streets have had parking control measures and removal of vehicles and this could be applied to other areas such as Prince Edwards road/hill for example
• Walking/Cycling more of this will follow once we remove the overwhelming numbers of cars and heavy vehicles from our roads
• Cycling Scheme not working very well. Bicycles getting trashed, hire bike locations sometimes found empty etc.?
• Walking and Cycling distances – Welcome recentcampaigns to promote walking and cycling
• Motorbike/Moped – lawlessness and numbers a concern
• Need for provision of clean transport vision for Town, Upper Rock and ‘outer Gibraltar’ tours to replace rising number of diesel buses that pollute where they go and when parked, whether MidTown or at sites of interest with idling engines.

6. BUNKERING/SHIPPING

a) Spills and Fumes – Significant improvement over the years, with greater resourcing and investment

b) VTS – Vessel Tracking Systems installed some years back, (an ESG campaign), now delivering higher safety shipping standards

c) Measures have been in place for some time now to direct vessels entering Gibraltar harbour/waters to switch to cleaner burning fuels, (still marine diesel but of a higher grade). This has had a clear impact as many vessels follow this requirement

d) Ships at anchor – should follow best practice and limit power generation to essential while in emission controlled areas (ECAs) to reduce harmful emissions close to shore. The Port Authority should also exert greater control over client vessels and bunkering barges, and the level of sooty emissions produced by some, on a regular basis. These cause high elevations of particulate and nitrogen dioxide levels, which threaten human health

e) Power supply – ship pollution from running engines at berth is now a principal environmental problem at many ports in Europe. Measures such as onshore power conversion and connection, are being introduced along with legislation to enforce ships in for repair or visiting for more than a day, to switch off their engines and connect to the local grid. The ESG has campaigned for some time to see this measure implemented and enforced in Gibraltar. Update: one site is currently being prepared to install cold ironing. Progress. Others should follow asap

c) Detached Mole –the berth for bulk fuel storage, and other services. ESG is concerned that while supporting a land-based fuel storage option over floating mother vessels, this mole does not represent the ideal solution. Greater use of vapour recovery technology is also essential to eliminate fumes, which periodically sweep through the town on certain fuel transfers at this site. However, while we understand this may change, there have been no vessels berthed here for some time. Conflict between fuelling at this site will only grow with the creation of a major residential reclamation directly opposite the mole (Victoria Keys)

7. CROSS BORDER ISSUES –

Co-operation – and contact continues between the ESG and Spanish Environmental NGOs. Long-term objectives shared include for a moratorium on industry and the need for an independent and rigorous cross border epidemiological study. Work is on going.

Complaint – the ESG acts as a watchdog on regional environmental issues and continues to file detailed complaints to the EU on the transgressions of pollution spikes usually from the CEPSA Oil Refinery. In February 2017 we lodged another complaint of excessive flaring by this industry, which was investigated against a background of our long-term complaints, and information lodged with the EU since 2002, with the assistance of Hassan’s International law Firm.

Western Beach – since April 2010, Western Beach has seen appalling and illegal levels of sewage contamination from a storm drain diversion pipe in La Linea. The ESG has campaigned hard on this at several levels. The contamination continues after a brief interlude of improvement, especially during the non-bathing months – mid September to mid April – when rainfall usually results in high levels of faecal contamination and E Coli. 9 years later and we still have this problem! Major MoD housing development has recently being constructed to the east of the beach, which may flag up issues of foul smells from the area over time. With the impending exit from the EU, we will no longer have MEPs to try and get EU support for attempting resolution of these cross border environment and health problems. A serious worry indeed.

Update: Roll back of existing Spanish Environmental protection measures and regulations

This situation is now producing grave concerns for our regional environment and must be challenged by Spain’s own environmental networks. These concerns include:

– The dismantling of the Junta de Andalucía’s Consejeria de Medio Ambiente thereby weakening an already poor oversight of environmental management of the Bays chemical industries and other practices

– Expansion of petrochemical industry despite the Europe wide call for action on the climate change crisis

– Major infill and reclamation at Algeciras port for fuel storage and container storage in an already congested part of the bay – destroying ecosystems and removing important feeding areas for migratory marine life

– Multiple large urbanisation projects approved to be built along the Costa de la Luz coastline, protected and valued as a primary tourist destination

– Roll back of protection of the environment in direct opposition to the EU drive for member states to respond to Climate Change and impacts from all quarters

8. EPIDEMIOLOGICAL STUDIES

 An independent, cross border epidemiological study is necessary because people on both sides of the border are deeply concerned about the high incidence of cancer and higher mortality that exists in many of the bay populations – cancer clusters have been identified in Sevilla, Cadiz and Huelva in a report led by Public Health WHO expert Professor Joan Benach who has acted as adviser to the Environmental groups. A triangle of higher mortality was ring-fenced by the professor whose research exposed close correlation between serious illness and mortality and heavy industries.

Gibraltar also suffers its share of cancers and given our location should be included in a bay wide independent study produced by epidemiologists with an environmental scientific background.

9. SEWAGE TREATMENT

Update: Detailed plans for a sewage treatment plant and location are now all in place. These have been presented to the DPC, who flagged up a number of issues, with most agreeing the scale and look of the plant was quite unacceptable at this location. So a revised plan is expected on this. ESG welcomed progress on this major project for Gibraltar. At the DPC we made our views known regarding the need to eliminate fugitive fumes and noise from the pumping station (Little Bay), and at the treatment site itself. Currently waiting for applicants on behalf of Government to return to DPC with more information as requested including landscape concerns.

We have also advocated for anaerobic digestion process to be included in the new treatment facility, aiding in odour reduction and converting waste to heat very efficiently. This, according to the applicant will be designed/planned once 6 months of operation at the plant have expired to provide a salinity picture to aid in the suitable digestion process. Still concerned over the high volume of sludge produced and need for exporting of this waste via the border, especially given Brexit considerations.

Qs: Bad smells pervade at certain locations of Gibraltar, which are nauseating for the driver, never mind the walker. Can these issues be resolved, or are they impossible to resolve? When will the treatment plant get going? We knew it would need to be after the major events of the summer but hope to see real movement here soon.

10. WASTE / RECYCLING / LITTER

Waste  Gibraltar needs a modern, purpose-built Waste Plant. Sites have become overwhelmed and a measure of reorganisation is underway. Never more than now, with the prospect of a hard or soft Brexit, does Gibraltar need a fit for purpose Waste Plant. Plans had been approved but then stalled.

Recycling  Hoping that recycling will become more efficiently resourced so that the positive levels produced by the Dept (and the community) continues to grow.

Litter  Gibraltar’s environment still suffers from littering. Believe clearer information of all facilities  (via signs, leaflets, media), improved street facilities (bins), enforcement (litter wardens), are all necessary. ESG has involved itself with Gibraltar’s littering issues since its first CUTW campaign in 2005. The campaign that enjoys widespread community support has a number of key aims, which have formed the backbone of a Litter Strategy and set of principles that the ESG works on throughout the year. Reports on every major clean up event are produced by the ESG, published, and submitted to the authorities and agencies. While more of our aims are being realised each year there is much that still needs to be done.

Update: Indeed 2019 has thrown up lots of issues for our campaign. Sites on the move – problematic border – elections and Brexit. These affect our ability to manage the ever-growing mountains of waste produced by a very busy tourist economy and high visitor turnover. Development and construction waste now at peak activity also adds to the pressure. Essentially the Clean up is about civic pride and pulling together, but also for sustained improvement. We believe that education/information, facilities/large &small, and enforcement/fines, to be the recipe for successful litter and waste control.

CUTW 2019 will assess, monitor and produce a review of where we are at regarding litter and waste issues and submit reports calling for urgent and appropriate actions.

11. PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT

Eplanning has clearly aided planning transparency and access to information

Gibraltar Development Plan has been contracted out which in the ESG’s view is a good idea. This way it will be completed quicker and will also follow widespread public consultation

New Town Planning Act passed unanimously in Parliament in the summer of 2018. The new Act saw widespread consultation that we took full advantage of and submitted our ideas also. Despite it being passed over a year ago it has still not been implemented and we have continued to see multiple Government projects announced for comment only which goes against the promises made by Government

Planning Schemes Additionally, the Chief Minister has ultimate say in the decisions on planning schemes – we interpret these as large areas. It is sometimes very difficult for some DPC members (including the ESG) to accept the scrutiny involved in overseeing smaller or private projects and pressing for debate/discussion on merits or otherwise, only to not have a voice on major planning schemes at all – these will have transformational impacts on the whole of Gibraltar, its landscapes and sustainability

Holistic and long-term planning It is therefore essential in our view to have sustainability in planning. Gibraltar’s limited land area (with or without reclamation) means that available space should be parcelled up holistically to cater for every need – from the poor, to the rich – in-betweeners and then breathing space!!

Green areas outside of gardens and reserves should be increased and made compulsory in all developments. This landscaping ought not to be part of a new development ‘somewhere’ but to take up street space to increase shade and life for the community

Five per cent of green area in a new development contained in the development plan is not always applied which is understandable in a town project but less so outside the city walls

Landscaping in large projects is essential to keep green, breathing spaces in our cityscape Update: recent announcements on retaining green areas and creating new ones is welcome

Sustainability in development – energy, water, waste and materials must be used to follow sustainable targets

Our climate change emergency demands that ALL activity in our community is screened for its contribution to CO2. All developments must be evaluated from the moment a project is conceived and will include every CO2 pound produced until such time as site is commissioned and then it will have a CO2 measured as energy efficiency – this is so far the only sustainable rating we have and must change. The ESG has raised this issue at DPC and there has been support for this new measure but it is not clear where or how this evaluation will be carried out or by who

Strategic Vistas and retaining Gibraltar’s well known iconic landscapes and profiles is also important to the ESG and is a measure included in previous development plans as an important tool but not so far resourced to be included in development in Gibraltar. Well, clearly it must be and we shall continue to press for this alongside the GONHS and Heritage Trust.

12.CONSERVATION

ESG is concerned that without a Gibraltar wide holistic plan our open, green spaces and coastal sites could be built upon even though these provide important breathing spaces and habitats in an otherwise increasingly urbanised environment. ESG also considers that major developments should incorporate more green areas and landscaping – See Planning for more information on this.

The ESG welcomes several new programmes led by the Department for the Environment, to better manage local biodiversity, protect important habitat and create awareness. We pride ourselves in raising awareness about litter and fly tipping in remote/green/coastal areas during our Clean up events, which have seen habitats improve, and greater focus given by the authorities. This is a campaign we have run since 2005.

Projects like Commonwealth Park have greatly enriched the town centre and further green projects announced are welcomed by the ESG.

13. EMF RADIATION

 EMF radiation from mobile phone masts and other WiFi equipment was part of an intense campaign by the ESG back in 2014-2015. It resulted in a Government policy on mast installation, which promoted the precautionary principle and holistic planning for all operators. This helped the overall situation considerably. As growing evidence on health impacts from this invisible pollution becomes available, especially on effects on young children, the elderly and infirm, we would like for more to be done in this area. For example, there are a growing number of countries that are banning WiFi in nurseries and first schools, and even within hospital wards, promoting the use of cabled alternatives. This is an on-going concern that we shall continue to discuss with the authorities, as greater awareness must be raised about potential health impacts on young children with the almost permanent use of ipads and other such equipment.

5G – Gibraltar continues to follow the spread of mobile technology, which is highly popular at a personal and business level. The ESG follows all aspects of this story given there are legitimate concerns raised about 5G by health and scientific professionals everywhere as well as from governing bodies from around the world.

Our issue isn’t that 5G is lethal and should not be installed in our hometown. Our issue is simply that if this new technology which is ‘milder” but effectively saturates exposure in order to provide a service – is not harmful in any way, then Government – as the ultimate authority – and companies wanting to bring this service in – are duty bound to provide reports/studies and reassurance to the public that concerns voiced globally are groundless. To date none have been forthcoming.

14. TOURISM IN THE UPPER ROCK

Mass tourism carries environmental impacts on wildlife and wilderness areas due to transport needs and numbers involved. Peak season sees large cruise liners, flights and thousands of cars entering Gibraltar on a monthly basis. This also impacts on infrastructure, facilities, traffic etc.

Upper Rock Management Plan A very comprehensive plan that saw widespread consultation and includes strong management recommendations. However what clearly hits you when in the upper rock is the absence of experienced rangers to ensure visitors and locals respect the environment and follow the rules. The sheer weight of numbers demands this should be in place. In peak season our macaques are subjected to dangerous levels of human interaction. Narrow roads create safety issues between walkers (that are being encouraged) and the endless stream of tourist carrying vehicles.

The possibility of a major increase in Cable car carrying capacity via a recent application by MH Bland, while being a more environmental mode of transport, poses significant issues in the top station area. Without a holistic Government plan managing numbers of people up there at any one time, this will present even more congestion than currently exists and will lower visitor experience even further. The safety issues presented by releasing high volumes of people potentially on foot every hour into the home of the macaques demands a holistic NEW transport plan be set in place – running on clean energy.

Litter issues are a problem in the upper rock due to the topography and we usually include a number of sites in our Clean up campaign.

Cruise Liners also present environmental issues and we are calling for careful evaluation of the impact from their funnel emissions while at berth.

15. ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION & MANAGEMENT PLAN  (EAMP) and more

Gibraltar signed up to the “Overseas Territories Environmental Charter” 14 years ago and some time after that produced Action Plans – last one in 2013, to roll out how different environmental impacts would be tackled and within what time frame. It is clearly well overdue and the ESG has been pressing Government for an update ever since.

The Plan could arguably be similar to what the public are calling for now with respect to climate change and a plan required, time lined, for that.

Indeed reducing environmental impacts as we have been campaigning for, for 20 years, would bring about benefits to the climate as well as to ourselves.

During the creation of an upgrade to the EAMP, the Government, especially in light of Brexit, has changed its plan to instead produce a different type of plan, based on the UK approach to sustainability and action on climate change. A short to medium to long-term approach.

While we support long term planning, we believe short and medium term actions should be clearly identified and ‘out there’, in order to get the community, both at a personal and at a business level, on side and preparing for changes ahead. We have been calling for its publication for some time now and the Climate Emergency Pledge and Crisis is now placing even greater pressure for this type of information to be published. We recognise that Brexit is also placing a lot of pressure on the Department of Environment and Government in general and is why we also support an independent climate body to focus exclusively on our decarbonising journey.

 We will lobby all parties for such a plan on all issues.

It is always been very clear to us that environmental issues and interests in Gibraltar need to be tackled and supported at a cross party level.  A short/medium and long term plan needed to decarbonise Gibraltar and make the difficult decisions we need to make today, demands cross party support and continuity.

Let 2019 be finally the year that our community delivers on historic promises to stand together for our environment  – we need to do this for ourselves, our children and for our planet.

ESG efforts since 2002 has seen, or placed pressure, for : 

The setting up of our Air Monitoring Stations

Independent air sampling via Bucket Brigade

Reduction in Bunkering Fumes

Environmental Policy

Initial Epidemiological Study

Recycling facilities and action on litter

Increased Environmental Awareness via outreach programmes, talks, community clean ups etc.

New Power Station Project get underway

Seat on the Development and Planning Commission (DPC)

CUTW Campaign aims receive Government support

Refurbishment of a number of CUTW hotspots

Cross border work on the CEPSA Oil Refinery and Sewage at Western Beach achieve results in Brussels

Cross border campaign result in Audit on CEPSA Refinery to set out a mandate for real change & clean-up

Radiation reduction efforts on mobile masts, etc. (see ESG Facebook page: Mobile Phone Mast Concern Gibraltar)

2014 – The ESG receive “A Group Heritage Award” in recognition of the value the Clean up the World Campaign represents for Gibraltar’s built and natural environment

2016 – The ESG receive an “Independent Civil Society Award” from Equality Rights Group in recognition and deep appreciation for the constant vigilance, dedication and disciplined hard work demonstrated by the group in the interests of safeguarding Gibraltar against encroaching dangers and degradation of its environment

2019 – The ESG is presented with a prestigious Global Energy Foundation Award for our work in our Clean up Campaign as well as in reducing pollution locally and regionally

2019 – ESG chairperson Janet Howitt awarded the Gibraltar Medallion of Excellence for her environmental work that has been possible due to the committed group of people that make up the ESG who have tirelessly campaigned for a better environment in Gibraltar since we formed in 2000

Visit ESG website: www.esg-gib.net for more information on our work and interests

Email us at: esg@gibtelecom.net

Keywords:  DPC / Queens Cinema / The Reserve / Plastic Cartridges / Recycling / Energy Globe award for CUTW!!

 

A few issues to highlight today as the summer period continues. In the past few weeks, at a regular, and then special, DPC session, applications have been discussed, agreed or deferred, some of these making news headlines. To start with there was a change of use regarding the end of a long standing and one of our few light industries, which is the glass factory. This site will now be converted to a new bank. Provisos were given as it passed through the initial outline planning stage and detailed discussion took place. Another project discussed and agreed was the demolition of the Queens Cinema, another link to our recent past. This end of chapter for this building was also given the go ahead albeit with a number of caveats to record heritage elements of value prior to demolition. The public response to the loss of this building brings sharply into focus the how and the why of planning in Gibraltar and how it is in constant flux. News then that the next Development Plan is being outsourced in order for this to be produced and go through all the hoops as expediently as possible is welcomed by the ESG. This means that during public consultation, the public, that’s all of us, have a chance to try and influence how Gibraltar is developed. Frameworks exist but must be improved and in a small place like Gibraltar, where planning is understandably contentious, this is highly critical.

 

We issued a press release this week regarding The Reserve – a large, high end apartment block presented to DPC once more at the site of the old casino. Given the unique setting of this site the ESG will continue to lobby for a more appropriate development that will respect and maintain the dynamics of the natural environment in this particular area.

 

Moving on to other matters and we wanted to state that we share concerns over the appearance of a high volume of plastic cartridge material washing up on our shores produced by a local shooting club. Despite the commendable efforts by all those involved in the Island Games to reduce env impacts from plastics and bottled water, this new plastic hazard has appeared with the games and must be stopped. Gibraltar has managed to run such activities by using more environmentally friendly, soluble, materials so the fact this has happened during a “Clean our Seas”, high profile, sporting event, raises serious questions. Its use must be banned and the clearing up of any remaining items undertaken before any further spread occurs.

 

But good news regarding the giant fish at eastern beach! After a mere couple of weeks this enormous structure was ¾’s full…. Of the right material!!! Clearly a good and bad thing as we realise just how much single use, disposal plastics we use on a day to day basis, even at the beach!! Still better in the fish than landfill or worse still in the seas. We are told that other such structures are planned for different beaches.

 

The ESG is honoured to have been presented with a national Energy Globe Award for the long standing CUTW campaign we have run since 2005 and for our efforts to work on local and regional pollution. Selected from over 2,000 projects, and alongside a few hundred others, this community wide campaign caught the attention of this prestigious body whose efforts serve to draw attention internationally of sustained, grassroots environmental projects carried out by NGOs around the world. The Gibraltar community should be proud of their incredible support and efforts for this campaign that has made it the success it is.

 

Finally, a quick word on the 5G issue. The ESG is following this matter up with Government and industry to ensure that safety, above all else is prioritised and will be issuing a separate statement on this very soon.

Please visit our website at esg-gib.net for all our press releases and more.

Stay cool and keep recycling!!